The OCC and FDIC’s joint final rule defining “unsafe or unsound practice” takes effect November 2. The rule requires that supervisory criticism be tied to material financial harm, and the FDIC has already determined that a “large majority” of its existing MRAs do not meet the new standard and are being closed. FDIC Chairman Travis Hill defended the rule against critics who say it ties examiner hands, stating that the definition includes “some nexus between the practice or activity and future potential harm” and does not require actual losses before criticism can be levied.
What you should do: If you face an MRA on a process issue with no material financial impact, ask whether it aligns with the new rule. Document your remediation and request completion when ready. But do not stop tracking observations: examiners retain discretion over CAMELS ratings.